Title: Powerful Members of Congress Demand Social Media Accountability, Despite Limited Enforcement Power
In an effort to hold tech platforms accountable for their content moderation practices, several influential members of Congress are demanding answers from major companies such as Facebook (Meta), TikTok, and Alphabet. While these appeals highlight the growing concerns over online content, the lack of congressional regulation, the protection of free speech, and the liability shield enjoyed by tech firms limit the ability of these officials to enforce change.
Sen. Michael Bennet has taken the lead by sending a letter to the leaders of major tech companies, requesting information on their content moderation measures. Similarly, Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers is demanding briefings from these companies to gain insights into their content moderation policies. Meanwhile, Rep. Frank Pallone is calling on Meta, Facebook, and YouTube to be more vigorous in enforcing their terms of service.
New York Attorney General Letitia James has also joined the chorus of voices demanding social media accountability. She has sent letters to multiple tech companies, including Google, Facebook, and TikTok, seeking answers on how they address calls for violence on their platforms.
Despite these efforts, the ability of US officials to force change is hampered by Congress’ failure to regulate online content and the protection of free speech guaranteed by the First Amendment. Additionally, tech firms enjoy a liability shield that provides them with legal immunity. This stands in stark contrast to the actions taken by the European Union, which has swiftly utilized its new Digital Services Act to investigate Facebook’s handling of violent content and issue warnings to platforms like TikTok and YouTube.
To compound matters, the White House has contacted social media companies directly to express concerns about their platforms. President Joe Biden has called for reforms to Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which currently shields platforms from liability. However, these efforts have yet to materialize into concrete action.
While Senator Bennet has proposed the creation of a federal regulator for social media, his bill lacks support and has not been taken up by a committee. Similarly, Attorney General James has introduced legislation alongside Governor Kathy Hochul to regulate harmful content on social media, but it won’t be considered until the legislature returns next year.
Tech platforms have attempted to showcase their commitment to addressing toxic content. YouTube has removed harmful videos and terminated channels, TikTok has removed hundreds of thousands of violating videos and increased its content moderation team, and Meta has taken steps to remove policy-violating videos.
In a positive light, the European Commission’s regulation of Big Tech has received praise from US representatives. This regulatory approach has centered on addressing disinformation and illegal content, particularly following the Hamas attack.
Despite mounting pressure, the White House has opted not to comment on these matters, leaving the issue of social media accountability unresolved.
As the need for social media accountability remains paramount, the actions and initiatives of powerful members of Congress continue to face significant challenges in enforcing change.
“Infuriatingly humble tv expert. Friendly student. Travel fanatic. Bacon fan. Unable to type with boxing gloves on.”